Obama Misleads On Tax Debate; Boehner Looks Foolish
December 23, 2011 7 Comments
Weepy Speaker John Boehner caved to Obama and the Senate Democrats by passing a two month extension of the 2% payroll tax cut from a year ago. Boehner and House Republicans were looking to extend it a year. The whole debate bordered on absurdity. The Senate passed the two month extension and then skipped town. Somehow it would be the House Republicans fault if the tax were increased. Never mind of course that the House passed a year long extension before the Senate passed their two month extension. Facts can be pesky things.
Speaking of pesky facts, Obama spent the better part of the past few days claiming that not extending the tax rate would cost middle class Americans $40 a week. Let’s do the math shall we? It’s a 2% tax hike if the tax was not extended. A family making $50,000 a year would see an additional $1,000 in tax, which works out to about $20 a week. Keep in mind the average family makes $50,000. In order to see a $40 tax hike you have to make $100,000 a year. Only about 20% of families make this much or more each year, meaning 80% make less. Obama was being disingenuous as usual.
But of course the President went over the top, running around DC with his dog and several pizza boxes claiming that family pizza night would be ruined if the House GOP didn’t pass the two month tax extension. Not only would family pizza night be ruined, but surely someone wouldn’t be able to afford gas to go visit their elderly father at the old folks home. We’ll pretend that not authorizing the Keystone pipeline isn’t responsible for that. Obama laid it on thick most of the day. He looked utterly ridiculous and unpresidential in doing so. But this has never stopped Obama before.
Speaker Boehner meanwhile comes off as a complete dufus. What was the point of this battle? Reasonable people can see that the House passed a year long tax rate extension before the Senate passed their two month extension. The Senate’s two month extension is ridiculous, most people understand that. But what did Boehner think he was going to gain by threatening not to pass the two month extension? Did he really think Harry Reid was going to call the Senate back to pass a full year extension?
Speaker Boehner had an oppertunity to run around the country accusing the Democrats of playing politics by passing a two month extension and making this issue come up again in February. He had the chance to scream to the high hills that the Democrats were going to threaten to increase middle class taxes in two months. Instead, Boehner threatened to let the tax increase unless the Senate passed a year extension. This was a pointless error. The only positive around this error is that it happened at a time of year when few are paying attention. But it was pointless nonetheless.
Everyone came off looking like a fool during this debate. Obama was misleading about how much the tax cut was really worth to middle class Americans and he looked ridiculous with his pizza boxes and sob stories. Boehner looks like an utter fool for having spent the week threatening not to pass a two month extension before passing it. Harry Reid and the Senate Democrats look like fools for only passing a two month extension in the first place. But let’s be honest, the big loser is Boehner because the left-wing media is setting up the story that way. In turn, it’s the GOP who lost here. One wonders for what purpose.